Public well being consultants say Robert F. Kennedy Jr is strictly who they thought he was.
The Well being and Human Companies (HHS) secretary — who can also be the nation’s most well-known vaccine skeptic — is remaking the company in his picture, casting doubt on the advantages of vaccines, and erecting new obstacles that can make it tougher for individuals who need photographs to get them, like requiring new vaccines to be examined towards placebos.
Throughout his affirmation hearings and different current congressional testimony, Kennedy sought to distance himself from the anti-vaccine motion.
He argued he’s merely searching for good information about vaccine security. He assured lawmakers he wouldn’t take away anybody’s vaccines and particularly pledged to Sen. Invoice Cassidy (R-La.) that he wouldn’t make any adjustments to the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention’s (CDC) vaccine advisory panel.
Whereas testifying at a Home Appropriations Committee listening to on Could 14, Kennedy mentioned his views on vaccines have been “irrelevant.”
“I don’t want to seem like I’m being evasive, but I don’t think people should be taking medical advice from me,” he instructed lawmakers, after being requested whether or not he would vaccinate his personal kids right now towards measles.
But prior to now week, Kennedy made an finish run across the conventional course of to vary the suggestions about who ought to get a COVID-19 vaccine.
He threatened to bar authorities scientists from publishing in main medical journals, and his workplace revoked a whole lot of thousands and thousands of {dollars} pledged to mRNA vaccine maker Moderna to develop, take a look at and buy photographs for pandemic flu.
Kennedy has been crucial of mRNA vaccines, and HHS mentioned the funding was canceled due to issues in regards to the security of “under-tested” mRNA expertise.
Georges Benjamin, government director of the American Public Well being Affiliation, mentioned the general public ought to take Kennedy at his phrase.
“He’s right. We shouldn’t trust him,” Benjamin mentioned. “He’s unbridled. He’s out of control, and so I am fearful that he will do more to undermine vaccine access and quality in the United States.”
Kennedy has a protracted historical past of opposition to vaccines. He petitioned the Meals and Drug Administration (FDA) in 2021 to revoke the emergency use authorizations of the COVID-19 vaccines and threatened to sue the company if it licensed COVID vaccines for kids.
His newest strikes to vary the COVID vaccine suggestions on wholesome kids and pregnant girls are elevating severe issues in regards to the potential to drag again on much more vaccines.
“What I see is COVID has provided this natural starting point … to sort of have that opening salvo in a bigger, longer-term effort to reconstruct, undermine vaccine policy,” mentioned Richard Hughes IV, an legal professional at Epstein Becker Inexperienced and former vp of public coverage at Moderna.
The choice to vary COVID vaccine coverage was introduced in a 58-second video clip shared on the social media web site X.
“I couldn’t be more pleased to announce that as of today the COVID vaccine for healthy children and healthy pregnant women has been removed from the CDC-recommended immunization schedule,” Kennedy mentioned.
Days after Kennedy’s pronouncement, the CDC issued new steerage that eliminated the advice for pregnant girls to get a COVID shot however stored the vaccine on the childhood immunization schedule.
The company modified the advice from its earlier wording of “should” to say wholesome kids “may” get the COVID vaccine after consulting with a well being supplier, an obvious contradiction to Kennedy’s plan.
Regardless of the brand new wording, the adjustments buck the normal methodology of constructing new vaccine suggestions.
The FDA decides whether or not to approve or authorize a vaccine, and the CDC’s impartial vaccine advisory panel convenes in an open public assembly to determine questions like who ought to get it, when and the way typically. It then sends suggestions to the CDC director, who can endorse or reject the suggestions.
The director almost at all times defers to the panel.
The HHS secretary isn’t usually concerned in vaccine selections, however there presently isn’t an appearing CDC director.
“We’re seeing a total side-stepping of the nation’s leading public health agency,” mentioned Richard Besser, a former appearing director of the CDC and president of the Robert Wooden Johnson Basis.
Besser mentioned medical doctors depend on the suggestions of federal well being consultants, that are presupposed to be primarily based on the perfect accessible science and proof. However medical doctors can’t be assured that is the case anymore, he mentioned.
Each Hughes and Benjamin mentioned different adjustments to HHS vaccine coverage are prone to be extra nuanced and delicate than the company’s actions on COVID.
“I would have said a couple months ago, obviously measles, obviously polio, those are childhood vaccines [that could be changed]. … But I think it’s going to be a little more subtle [than banning a shot]. It’s going to be a little more slow,” Hughes mentioned.
In April, the CDC’s vaccine advisers met after a two-month delay to vote on suggestions for chikungunya vaccines, meningitis vaccines and respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) vaccines.
A few month later, Kennedy personally signed off on suggestions for the chikungunya shot.
He has not acted on the opposite suggestions from the panel’s April assembly, together with using a brand new meningitis vaccine and an growth of RSV vaccines to high-risk adults ages 50-59.
The vaccine panel isn’t scheduled to vote on COVID vaccine suggestions till late June. Specialists mentioned it will be essential to hearken to what the panel members say, and whether or not they really feel they’ve the liberty to debate HHS’s current actions.
“You’ve got a committee of advisers who were cut out of the loop. How are they going to handle that in a public forum?” Benjamin mentioned.
